Everything You Need To Know About Royal Icing

Want to create bakery-quality decorated cookies at home? This classic sugar cookie icing—also known as royal icing—is a smooth, glossy frosting that hardens perfectly, making it ideal for intricate designs on cookies, cakes, and gingerbread houses. Whether you prefer a traditional royal icing recipe with egg whites or a no-meringue powder version, this guide covers everything you need to know, from consistency tips to expert decorating techniques. Plus, I’ll share the techniques I’ve learned through years of decorating, so you can confidently create beautiful, bakery-style cookies at home.

As a passionate home baker, I’ve spent years perfecting sugar cookie icing techniques, testing different recipes, and learning how to get just the right consistency for decorating. I’ve decorated countless cookies for birthdays, holidays, and special events, and through trial and error, I’ve learned the best methods to achieve smooth, perfectly piped designs. In this guide, I’ll share my experience along with expert-backed tips to help you create stunning royal icing decorations at home.”

What Is Royal Icing and What Is It Used For?

Royal icing is a sugary icing that is made from beaten egg whites, confectioner’s sugar and sometimes vanilla extract or lemon juice. It has a smooth, semi-solid consistency when made and then dries hard. Royal icing can be tinted with food coloring or gel and is often used to decorate sugar cookies, gingerbread houses, and more. 

What Does Royal Icing Taste Like?

Royal icing is sweet and tastes like sugar, as the main ingredient is sugar. Depending on the ingredients used to make the royal icing, the flavor may change subtly. If vanilla extract is used, then the royal icing will have a slight hint of vanilla flavor. Lemon juice can also be added, which will then give the royal icing a lemon flavor. Hint: if using vanilla extract is preferred, a clear vanilla extract may be used to ensure the white color of the royal icing is not altered.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure here.

How to Add Color to Your Sugar Cookie Icing

All royal icing is white when it is first made. In order to change or add colors, food coloring or gel needs to be added. Depending on the shade / tint you want the color of your royal icing to be, the amount of food coloring or gel will vary.

💡 Note: a little food coloring or gel goes a long way. Always start with the motto, “less is more” and add more color if needed. If you have achieved too dark or rich of a color, simply add in more plain white royal icing to lighten your color.

How to Properly Dry and Harden Your Icing for a Perfect Finish

Royal icing dries to a “softer” hard, a semi-firm consistency. Not hard candy-like hard, but rather a very cold stick of butter hardness. Once royal icing has been applied to your cookies, cakes, biscuits, etc it will dry on its own from the air within minutes to a few hours. However, royal icing can sometimes take a while to dry or actually never fully “hardened” and is easily maneuvered by simply touching the royal icing.

There are a few factors that can make royal icing not dry / harden properly. If the room is humid, the drying time will be much longer. You may need to use a fan or dehumidifier to help dry the cookies faster. If the consistency of your royal icing was too runny / liquid-y then this will also increase the dry time. Try adding more confectioners sugar to your royal icing to help thicken the consistency to help it dry faster / stiffer.

How Long Is Royal Icing Good For / How Long Does It Keep?

Royal icing stored in the refrigerator can be used for up to one week. Royal icing can be stored in piping bags or in ziplock baggies or lid tight containers.

Can I Freeze Royal Icing?

Yes, royal icing can be placed in the freezer and kept for up to three months. Be sure to to store your royal icing properly in an air-tight bag or container to help avoid freeze burn. It is also helpful to store your royal icing flat. Note: colored or tinted royal icing may separate in the freezer and will need to be stirred again when removed from the freezer. 

How To Thaw Frozen Royal Icing?

Thawing royal icing is quite easy. Remove from the freezer and set on a flat surface, ideally a kitchen counter. Allow to defrost at room temperature. Once the royal icing has become malleable, you can remove it from the bags or container and use.

Mastering Icing Consistency – Piping, Flooding, and Outlining Techniques

Royal icing consistencies are described generally in three different categories.

• Piping: Generally used for writing letters or creating designs. Piping consistency is often compared to the same consistency as  toothpaste, pudding or soft-served ice cream.
• Medium: Generally used for outlining. Medium consistency is often compared to the same consistency as ketchup or ranch dressing.
• Flood: Generally used to fill in the outlining. Flood consistency is often compared to the same consistency as shampoo or honey.

What is The Difference Between Royal Icing and Fondant?

Royal icing and fondant are two types of icings typically used for cookie and cake decorating. While they are both sweet in taste and can be used in similar situations, there are specific times in which one or the other should be chosen. 

• Royal icing: is primarily made with confectioners sugar and egg whites. It is typically applied using piping bags and decorator tips. It is more of a liquid substance that dries semi-firm. Royal icing is often times used as “edible glue” to hold together gingerbread house walls.
• Fondant: is primarily made of confectioners sugar, corn syrup, water, and gelatin. Fondant is typically rolled out with a rolling pin and used to cover an entire cake layer, etc. 

What is The Difference Between Royal Icing and Buttercream Frosting?

Royal icing and buttercream frosting can both be used for decorating cakes or cookies, however, there are some major differences.

• Royal icing: as described above, is thin and stiff and is often used for smaller, more intricate, decorative purposes. 
• Buttercream frosting: is made from confectioners sugar, milk or cream, butter and extract. Buttercream is often used to cover an entire cake or cookie, similar to fondant. Buttercream does not dry hard / stiff as royal icing, instead it dries like typical cake frosting.

Tools / Supplies to Use For Royal Icing

Many tools and supplies can be used to achieve the desired look and effect of royal icing. 

• Piping bags: a cone-shaped pastry bag that is made from cloth, paper or plastic and is used to pipe semi-solid foods through the narrow opening on one end.
• Decorator tips: interchangeable sizes and designed tips that comes in either plastic or metal that twist on to a piping bag using a coupler system. 

How To Decorate Sugar Cookies with Royal Icing

Cookie decorating frosting is often applied using pastry bags, sometimes referred to as bakers’ piping bags, along with interchangeable decorator tips to create different designs and thicknesses. Royal icing can also be applied in a spreading fashion using a spatula or a butter knife. The design possibilities with royal icing are endless! From delicate piping to bold flood designs, you can customize every detail to match any theme or occasion.

Need inspiration? Check out my decorating tutorials below:

No-Fail Royal Icing Recipe

The key to beautifully decorated cookies starts with the right icing! After years of perfecting my technique, I’ve created a No-Fail Homemade Royal Icing for Sugar Cookies, which you can find here: 👉 No-Fail Homemade Royal Icing for Sugar Cookies

This recipe is:

• Simple & beginner-friendly with step-by-step instructions
• Versatile – great for piping, flooding, and intricate designs
• Easy to tint – customize with food coloring or gel for vibrant designs

This foolproof icing dries to a smooth, glossy finish that hardens beautifully – perfect for decorated cookies, cakes, and more. Click the link above to get the full recipe and start decorating with confidence!